The HMA Law Firm - Immigration & Criminal Defense Lawyers

Call: 703.964.0245

  • Home
  • Our Team
  • Practice
    • Immigration >
      • Employment-Based Immigration >
        • The H-1B Visa
        • Investor and Intracompany Transfers (E & L Visas)
        • PERM Labor Certification >
          • Cross Chargeability
          • EB-5 Green Cards
      • Marriage & Fiancé Visas >
        • Special Service for Servicemen
        • Marriage Interview Questions
        • The I-751 Good Faith Waiver
        • Evidence for Filing an I-751
        • My I-751 Was Denied: Now What?
        • Same-Sex Marriage Immigration Issues
        • New 90 Day Rule
      • General Immigration >
        • Filing a FOIA from USCIS
        • Form G-639: How to Complete
        • Re-Entry Permits
        • TPS >
          • More on TPS
          • SYRIA TPS
          • TPS Yemen
        • U Visas
      • Legal Victories
      • How To Choose The Right Immigration Lawyer
      • Waivers (I-601/I-601A) >
        • Drunk Driving (DUI/DWI) and I-601/I-601A Waivers
      • Citizenship >
        • N-648 Medical Waivers
        • Naturalization Pitfalls
        • The Civics Test for Naturalization
        • Exceptions for English Test
        • Criminal Convictions and Naturalization
      • Mandamus: It's Taking Too Long >
        • Mandamus: What to Think, What to Expect
        • How an Immigration Writ of Mandamus Works
        • Petition for Hearing on Naturalization
      • Deportation Defense >
        • Overview of Removal Proceedings
        • Deportation: Preventive Maintenance
      • Deferred Action (DACA) >
        • To Lawyer Or Not To Lawyer
        • Applying for a Social Security Number
    • Criminal Defense >
      • Traffic Offenses
    • Learn >
      • Immigration In A Nutshell >
        • The Visa Bulletin and Family Immigration
      • Criminal Immigration Law 101 >
        • Know Your Rights
      • Eligibility for Citizenship >
        • Citizenship versus Naturalization
        • Why Become a Citizen?
  • Consult/Pay Fees
  • Testimonials
  • Careers
  • Blawg
  • En Español
    • Accion Ejecutiva
    • El Interdicto Temporal
    • Buscar Detenido
    • Reforma Inmigratoria
    • Papeles Por Los Indocumentados

The HMA Law Firm Blawg

    Question? Contact a lawyer now!

Submit

Proving Physical Presence - A Picture Is Worth A Thousand Words

11/15/2013

52 Comments

 
Picture
Immigration applications frequently require the applicant to prove that he or she was physically present in the United States on a certain date.

Back in the days of 245(i), it was proving physical presence on December 21, 2000.  For cancellation of removal, you have to show 10 years in the US.  For deferred action, or DACA, you have to show you were under 16 and in the US prior to June 15, 2007.

And so a lot of people run into problems.  If you don't have status, you might not have a paycheck stub or a rental or lease agreement.  Any pictures you might have are probably undated.

That's where creativity comes in.  As lawyers trying to find the best way to help our clients, sometimes it's the small things that can make a huge difference.

A young Dreamer came to see us who entered the US at age 14, but since she didn't start school until 16, she had no proof that she was in the United States when she was under 16.

I told her, bring anything you can from that time period.  All she could find were three pictures.  They were taken when she was 14, and they happened to be from a sightseeing trip in Washington, DC.  That was good: it's easy to tell the pictures were taken in the United States.

But there was no date on the pictures.  I looked on the back; no photo date print, either.  The pictures could have been taken in 1993, 2003, or 2013; there was no way to tell.

I usually look for pictures of cars.  If it's close enough, one good way is to look at the license plates and see the month and year the plates expired.  Yes, it's possible for someone to drive around with expired tags - but remember, the burden of proof is a preponderance of the evidence - you only have to show a 51% likelihood.

There were no cars in any of the pictures, unfortunately.

But then I noticed a construction barrier in one picture around the Washington Monument.  I asked my client if she got to see the Monument that day, and she said no, it was closed.  A quick Google search pulled up articles that the Monument was closed in September 2004 and reopened in April 2005.  During that time, there were indeed "Jersey walls" - movable concrete barriers - to close the Monument to pedestrian, vehicle and tourist traffic.

Now, it's possible that the photograph was "Photoshopped."  It's possible the Monument was closed after my client turned 16.  It's possible that...

But again - it's important to remember the burden of proof.  By using these pictures as documentary evidence supporting an affidavit, that burden was sustained, and USCIS approved the deferred action application.

Years ago we had a 245(i) case wherein we proved physical presence in December 2000 with a picture that showed the applicant at a Home Depot, wearing an orange apron with his name and a logo that said "Proud Sponsor - Sydney Olympic Games" and - what Providence - there happened to be a Christmas tree in the background.  (The Olympics were held in Sydney, Australia in the year 2000).

More frequently, we use tagged photos on Facebook; while individually they might not carry much weight, photos that have been tagged and commented on by multitudes of people are much harder to fake.

The point is, as I've advised my clients many times - it's impossible to live in the United States and not leave a trail.  You just have to know what you're looking for.  And a picture is usually worth a thousand words.

Hassan M. Ahmad, Esq.

52 Comments
Kizi 1 link
11/15/2013 03:52:59 pm

it was very interesting but it brings many emotions

Reply
Kizi 4 link
11/15/2013 03:54:10 pm

thanks very good

Reply
Yepi 2 link
11/15/2013 03:54:49 pm

great today! i like it

Reply
Michael Piston link
11/18/2013 04:52:37 am

Nice thinking outside the box Mr. Ahmad!

Reply
frivjuego link
1/16/2014 04:10:38 am

Really interesting information, so thank you for everything.

Reply
Para jugar link
2/23/2014 04:08:16 am

It really is a good app to be able to more easily manage the present time for those who reside here.

Reply
Hopy link
3/4/2014 06:25:21 pm

Thank you for this post.

Reply
friv 10 link
7/10/2014 09:19:21 pm

Thanks for this informative post. It help me a lot. And it gave mo ideas on how to make more money in marketing business. I hope lots of people visit this site so they can easily learn this informative post.

Reply
friv2g link
7/20/2014 04:25:31 pm

I get a lot of great information here and this is what I am searching for. Thank you for your sharing.

Reply
Friv link
8/25/2014 07:51:10 pm

Excellent Blog! I would like to thank for the efforts you have made in writing this post.

Reply
freejobalert link
8/28/2014 10:18:53 pm

After all, when I finishing the whole article, i feel I have learned too much, I appreciated your writing style.
<a href="http://www.freshersworld24.in">freejobalert</a>

Reply
girls go games link
8/29/2014 05:06:35 pm

I am delighted to be a visitant of this website!

Reply
Didi games link
8/29/2014 05:07:05 pm

I like the flash and free games.

Reply
Friv 300 link
9/15/2014 03:09:13 pm

I agree that it is very interesting and helpful, thanks

Reply
Girl Games link
9/26/2014 02:01:18 pm

This is something special! never seen this before! thank you

Reply
Friv 20 link
10/8/2014 09:54:59 pm

Please keep us up to date like this. Thanks for sharing.

Reply
G9G link
10/14/2014 06:24:14 pm

Thanks for sharing the article good information, it will add new things to my store of knowledge

Reply
Kizi link
10/14/2014 06:26:31 pm

very cool . I like it

Reply
Huz 10 link
10/14/2014 06:27:25 pm

very nice . thank for sharing information

Reply
a10 games link
10/19/2014 02:45:00 am

great article, full of useful information for me, people will remember and be grateful for your contribution. thank you

Reply
Friv 4 link
10/27/2014 02:44:55 pm

And it gave mo ideas on how to make more money in marketing business.

Reply
Games2Win link
11/17/2014 07:26:59 pm

I hope lots of people visit this site so they can easily learn this informative post.

Reply
Kizi link
1/13/2015 08:48:25 pm

Very happy. Thank you for share

Reply
Kizi link
3/11/2015 03:33:40 pm

Its like you read my mind! You seem to know a lot about this, like you wrote the book in it or something.

Reply
Kizi 5 link
4/28/2015 12:52:54 pm

Posts shared useful information and meaningful life, I'm glad to be reading this article and hope to soon learn the next article. thank you

Reply
Yepi link
6/2/2015 09:32:49 pm

What a wonderfull post! thank you... read with pleasure!
http://www.kizi200games.net/

Reply
Frvi link
6/18/2015 09:03:23 pm

Nice read. Very good post for fun and some time pass. Thanks for sharing.
http://www.yepi1online.net/ | http://www.friv5online.biz/

Reply
Friv 4 School link
7/7/2015 09:36:35 pm

you always bring everyone the most interesting and useful, I like it all, thank you.
http://www.friv1000gamess.com/
http://www.friv2online.org/

Reply
Kizi 50 link
7/14/2015 12:19:17 am

thank you verry much

Reply
Friv 2015 link
7/16/2015 04:12:21 pm

what do you do

Reply
Kizi link
7/24/2015 03:35:26 am

Well, you shared a informative information with everyone and Thank you for that

Reply
Friv link
8/6/2015 08:45:56 pm

would you rather do on the holidays

Reply
Friv link
3/20/2016 04:22:57 am

Thanks for posting this useful info. It really helped me!!!

Reply
Marina
6/29/2016 12:00:42 am

That was a great info. My husband came to the us in 1999 but like you said, had no formal job, rent agreement, etc. I am not sure if we can find a picture either. Any other thoughts?

Reply
Hassan Ahmad
6/29/2016 12:15:45 pm

If you don't have a picture, maybe some of his friends do from back then. You have to go through the due diligence and working with a lawyer can help you do this.

If you still come up empty, sometimes just showing that you did everything you could can be enough.

See this post:

http://www.hmalegal.com/blawg/deferred-actionnot-deferred

Reply
Friv Games link
7/4/2016 09:36:05 pm

Good job. All of them are Useful! ..
http://www.friv4-games.net

Reply
Happy Wheels link
7/8/2016 12:37:11 am

We offers a selection of the best games on the web, including exclusive games. Play now for free!
http://www.kizi2-games.net

Reply
Y1 Games link
8/25/2016 10:45:46 am

Well, you shared a informative information with everyone and Thank you for that
Reply

Reply
Y4 Games link
8/25/2016 10:48:23 am

Very happy. Thank you for share
Reply

Reply
Fynsy link
8/30/2016 10:31:06 am

thanks you

Reply
Abcya link
9/2/2016 07:56:47 pm

I must thank you for the efforts you've put in penning this blog. excellent blog post .
<a href="http://www.abcyaforschool.com" title="Abcya">Abcya</a> - <a href="http://www.games4girl.net" title="Games4Girls">Games4Girls</a> - <a href="http://www.minecraft100games.com" title="Minecraft Games">Minecraft Games</a>

Reply
kizigame link
9/5/2016 04:25:35 am


Thank you for your post, I look for such article along time, today i find it finally. this post give me lots of advise it is very useful for me
---------------------------------------------------------------------
<a href="http://www.kizi100game.net" title="kizigames">kizigames</a> | <a href="http://www.happywheelsgames.org" title="happywheelsgames">happywheelsgames</a> | <a href="http://www.friv4kidsgames.com" title="friv4kidsgames">friv4kidsgames</a>

Reply
Friv 2017 link
9/7/2016 09:32:43 pm


Posts shared useful information and meaningful life, I’m glad to be reading this article and hope to soon learn the next article. thank you - <a href="http://www.friv2017com.com" title="Friv 2017">Friv 2017</a> - <a href="http://www.abcyaonline.com" title="Abcya">Abcya</a> - <a href="http://www.minecraftgames4free.com" title="Minecraft Games">Minecraft Games</a>

Reply
Friv10000 link
9/24/2016 05:14:22 am

Thanks for sharing the information. It is very useful for my future. keep sharing. Can you play more games at:
Friv10000 ==> http://www.friv10000play.com/
Kizi ==> http://www.kizi4play.com/
happy wheels ==> http://www.happywheelsgameplay.com/

Reply
Friv 1000 link
9/26/2016 09:11:35 pm

Y8 update new free Cartoon Games online from Y8.com. Y8 Games is a free online cartoon flash games site where you can find games from all your favorite cartoons such as.

Reply
Happy Wheels link
9/26/2016 09:23:00 pm

Wow great today, good luck.
http://www.friv2gamesplay.com/
http://www.friv4gamesplay.com

Reply
baixar banana kong link
10/24/2016 03:35:49 am

Thanks for sharing the information. It is very useful for my future. keep sharing.

Reply
subway surfer link
10/24/2016 03:36:53 am

let's click tank trouble to play for free the best flash games

Reply
dream league soccer link
10/24/2016 03:37:23 am

We offers a selection of the best games on the web, including exclusive games. Play now for free!

Reply
Friv 4 link
12/24/2016 08:35:25 am

Thanks for sharing this good stuff! Keep up the great work, we look forward to reading more from you in the future!

Reply
Kizi 100 link
7/7/2017 09:58:58 pm

A very good analysis makes the strong success of the Nike brand
http://www.kizi2-com.com
http://www.kizi10-com.com
http://www.friv3-online.com

Reply
Didi Games link
5/8/2018 03:42:20 am

Give me a break at the game I like
http://www.y9-com.com
http://www.kizi2plus.com

Reply

Your comment will be posted after it is approved.


Leave a Reply.

    DISCLAIMER: If a blog post you read here contains case results, be advised that case results depend upon a variety of factors unique to each case. Case results do not guarantee or predict a similar result in any future case.

    Authors

    Sharifa Abbasi, Esq.
    Hassan M. Ahmad, Esq.
    Humza Kazmi, Esq.
    Faisal Khan
    ​Valeria Prudencio
    Carly Stadum-Liang, Esq.

    Archives

    September 2020
    August 2020
    July 2018
    June 2018
    April 2018
    March 2018
    February 2018
    January 2018
    December 2017
    November 2017
    October 2017
    September 2017
    July 2017
    June 2017
    May 2017
    April 2017
    March 2017
    February 2017
    January 2017
    December 2016
    November 2016
    October 2016
    September 2016
    August 2016
    July 2016
    June 2016
    May 2016
    March 2016
    February 2016
    January 2016
    December 2015
    November 2015
    August 2015
    June 2015
    May 2015
    April 2015
    March 2015
    February 2015
    January 2015
    May 2014
    April 2014
    January 2014
    December 2013
    November 2013
    October 2013
    September 2013
    August 2013
    July 2013
    June 2013
    May 2013
    April 2013
    March 2013
    February 2013
    January 2013
    December 2012
    October 2012
    September 2012
    August 2012
    July 2012
    June 2012
    April 2012
    January 2012
    December 2011
    August 2011
    March 2011
    February 2011
    July 2010
    April 2010
    March 2010
    February 2010

    Categories

    All
    Appellate
    Asylum
    CBP
    Citizenship
    Constitutional Rights
    Criminal
    DACA
    Deportation
    Family
    Framing
    General
    H 1B
    H-1B
    Hma Law Firm
    Immigration
    Immigration Policy
    Immigration Reform
    International
    Interns
    Muslim Ban
    National Security
    Politics
    Removal
    Syria
    Tanton FOIA Lawsuit
    Trump
    Waivers

    RSS Feed

Quick Links

  • Our Team
  • Practice Areas
  • Executive Action
  • Consult

Contact Info

8133 Leesburg Pike, Ste 801
Vienna VA 22182

Tel:  703.964.0245

Fax: 703.997.8556
Email: info@hmalegal.com

Subscribe to the HMA LawFeed

Picture

​Pay Fees Here

©2009 - 2021 by Hassan M. Ahmad. All rights reserved. No portion of this website may be copied or reproduced for any purpose without express written permission.

Photos used under Creative Commons from Beshroffline, Thorne Enterprises, alex-s, swanksalot, 401(K) 2012, hyku, Gage Skidmore, Gage Skidmore, michaeln3, Antony J Shepherd, Korean Resource Center 민족학교, Don Fulano, lewebafricain, Images_of_Money, Lord Jim, Kevinth Nunez, Joe Crimmings Photography, Cohen.Canada, Thane Eichenauer, Gage Skidmore, CGP Grey, digitalshay, anokarina, Debbie Ramone, slightly everything, loop_oh, aaron_anderer, U.S. Marshals Service, tsuacctnt, Andrew Feinberg, Official U.S. Navy Imagery, Soggydan, Keith Bacongco, photosteve101, Emery Co Photo, futureatlas.com, david_terrar, weiss_paarz_photos, juanktru, Anh Le Tran's Photogphy, Amanda M Hatfield, IcronticPrime, Fibonacci Blue, blvesboy, Carl Montgomery, zappowbang, khawkins04, kennethkonica, opensourceway, Supernico26, mynameisharsha, JBrazito, Glyn Lowe Photoworks, Justin A. Wilcox, Wesley Fryer, MAClarke21, khalid Albaih, Chairman of the Joint Chiefs of Staff