The HMA Law Firm - Immigration & Criminal Defense Lawyers

Call: 703.964.0245

  • Home
  • Our Team
  • Practice
    • Immigration >
      • Employment-Based Immigration >
        • The H-1B Visa
        • Investor and Intracompany Transfers (E & L Visas)
        • PERM Labor Certification >
          • Cross Chargeability
          • EB-5 Green Cards
      • Marriage & Fiancé Visas >
        • Special Service for Servicemen
        • Marriage Interview Questions
        • The I-751 Good Faith Waiver
        • Evidence for Filing an I-751
        • My I-751 Was Denied: Now What?
        • Same-Sex Marriage Immigration Issues
        • New 90 Day Rule
      • General Immigration >
        • Filing a FOIA from USCIS
        • Form G-639: How to Complete
        • Re-Entry Permits
        • TPS >
          • More on TPS
          • SYRIA TPS
          • TPS Yemen
        • U Visas
      • Legal Victories
      • How To Choose The Right Immigration Lawyer
      • Waivers (I-601/I-601A) >
        • Drunk Driving (DUI/DWI) and I-601/I-601A Waivers
      • Citizenship >
        • N-648 Medical Waivers
        • Naturalization Pitfalls
        • The Civics Test for Naturalization
        • Exceptions for English Test
        • Criminal Convictions and Naturalization
      • Mandamus: It's Taking Too Long >
        • Mandamus: What to Think, What to Expect
        • How an Immigration Writ of Mandamus Works
        • Petition for Hearing on Naturalization
      • Deportation Defense >
        • Overview of Removal Proceedings
        • Deportation: Preventive Maintenance
      • Deferred Action (DACA) >
        • To Lawyer Or Not To Lawyer
        • Applying for a Social Security Number
    • Criminal Defense >
      • Traffic Offenses
    • Learn >
      • Immigration In A Nutshell >
        • The Visa Bulletin and Family Immigration
      • Criminal Immigration Law 101 >
        • Know Your Rights
      • Eligibility for Citizenship >
        • Citizenship versus Naturalization
        • Why Become a Citizen?
  • Consult/Pay Fees
  • Testimonials
  • Careers
  • Blawg
  • En Español
    • Accion Ejecutiva
    • El Interdicto Temporal
    • Buscar Detenido
    • Reforma Inmigratoria
    • Papeles Por Los Indocumentados

The HMA Law Firm Blawg

    Question? Contact a lawyer now!

Submit

Padilla v. Kentucky: A Change is Gonna Come

4/11/2010

18 Comments

 
On March 31, 2010 the US Supreme Court handed down a 7-2 decision in the case of Padilla v. Kentucky, 559 U.S. _____ (2010).  And boy, have we been waiting on this one.

Briefly, the case is about a long-term green card holder who was given a piece of very bad advice by his lawyer when pleading guilty to a drug offense.   The Sixth Amendment to the US Constitution guarantees that all criminal defendants will have a competent lawyer for their defense.  So the question is, is it incompetence if a lawyer either gives wrong advice or fails to advise his client about the clear risk of deportation?

The lower courts all said no, reasoning that deportation is not a direct criminal consequence of a guilty plea, so a criminal defense attorney has no duty to advise his client of it.  The defense attorney has to advise his client, for example, that he is giving up his right to appeal, to a trial, to confront witnesses against him, to the presumption of innocence, and many other rights, because these are direct consequences of a guilty plea.  But there are other potential consequences: ineligibility to vote, difficulty in finding a job, or loss of security clearance. 

What about deportation?  The lower courts found that deportation is not a direct consequence, but a collateral (or indirect) consequence of pleading guilty.  And these courts refused to place a duty on the defense attorney to advise about deportation, saying in effect it was the same as other indirect consequences, like ineligibility to vote.

The Supreme Court, thankfully, saw differently. It rejected this whole distinction between direct and collateral.  It is an artificial distinction, it has actually never been used, in this context, and it invites absurd results, allowing a defense attorney to misadvise his client regarding what may be the most important factor in his decision to plead guilty.  Even worse, it allows a defense attorney who does not know immigration law to merely remain silent, and fail to advise his client about what may be the most important factor in his decision to plead guilty.

Although deportation has long been considered a "drastic measure," (see Fong Haw Tan v. Phelan, 333 U. S. 6, 10 (1948)) this is the first time the Court has found that because deportation is "intimately related to the criminal process" the defense attorney has an affirmative duty to advise about it correctly.  Other immigration consequences (such as ineligibility for naturalization, or eligibility for some form of relief in removal proceedings) should also be advised about, but the Court did not place the duty of knowing all immigration law on the shoulders of defense counsel.  Rather, the duty extends to saying, "Pleading guilty may have some adverse consequences," but if the risk of deportation is truly clear (e.g., the conviction is considered an aggravated felony by the immigration law) then the advice must be, "Pleading guilty will likely result in your deportation from the United States."

In my opinion, this is an important case.  But more importantly, I believe this will become a very important case.  Why?  Because for the first time, the highest court in the land has come down definitively to say that "changes to our immigration law have dramatically raised the stakes of a noncitizen’s criminal conviction," and further that the Court found it "most difficult" to divorce the penalty from the conviction in the deportation context.  The law has severely limited judicial review, taken away the old trump card of the JRAD (judicial recommendation against deportation), made deportation virtually automatic for an ever increasing list of offenses, and has exalted form over function in the criminal immigration law.  This is the first time since IIRAIRA in 1996 that the Court has recognized that the current law is so strict that it can easily impinge on an individual's constitutional rights.  Deportation breaks up families and causes untold hardships on innocent people, the same as a criminal conviction.  I am not suggesting that the law treat immigrants and citizens the same in all contexts.  But to demote deportation to a "collateral civil consequence" like ineligibility to vote is just ludicrous.

It's time to start using common sense and stop pretending that a Vietnam veteran like Padilla who's been in the country for 40 years has the same rights as a person who overstayed their visa last month.  The system can't have it both ways: first making this incredibly complex (and frequently nonsensical) criminal immigration law with the power to automatically deport, but at the same time tell defense attorneys that there's no need to advise their clients about any of it. 

The Court's decision, to me, represents the dawning awareness that people's lives should not be easily destroyable. 

If you have a criminal conviction that has made you removable from the United States, contact an attorney to see if this new decision opens up any new options for you.
Picture
18 Comments
DUI Lawyer Lake Tahoe CA link
10/11/2013 12:45:17 am

Its really bad to know that your lawyer gave you bad advice. It is always advisable to concern with more then one lawyer before taking the action.

Reply
rangeukonline.co.uk link
11/9/2013 09:38:38 pm

Your teacher is just grading all outputs of the essay writing tasks that he or she assigns to you. So do not blame him or her if your recently-submitted essay didn't pass his or her standards.

Reply
eaglehealthcarepro.com link
11/18/2013 05:33:02 am

I have been reading in a class and we are looking at this subject in the next week. I will be assign my student to look at your post for good information.

Reply
shahidsaleemali link
4/2/2014 02:02:40 am

very helpful and useful ideas and tips about home decorate and design, that how to decorate our home. for example rooms, bathroom and kitchen color combination, furniture design, fabrics design and color.
http://www.sleepy-hollow-design.com/
http://www.aquasoleilspa.com/

Reply
jhonhappy link
4/22/2014 10:52:01 pm

I have been reading in a class and we are looking at this subject in the next week. I will be assign my student to look at your post for good information.

Reply
shahidsaleemali link
4/23/2014 01:53:49 am

Now You Booked Hotel Rooms In Every Place, Home, Office, And Others. Book Top And Luxury Hotel In The France, Australian, Europe and Dubai. And Get Traveling Tips And Ideas For Our.
http://www.hotel-austral.com/

Reply
shahidsaleemali link
4/23/2014 01:54:36 am

If You Want Purchase A Used Car. Then You Vsit This Because In This Very Useful Ideas And Tips For Car. And Tips To Reduce Car Insurance Quotes. And many More For Used Cars.
http://clayton-usedcars.com/

Reply
karwanpak
4/24/2014 01:36:23 am

I have been reading in a class and we are looking at this subject in the next week. I will be assign my student to look at your post for good information.


OZGECELIKEV.COM
HANDELONTHELAWTV.COM

Reply
shahidsaleemali link
4/25/2014 12:02:41 am

Fashion News And Fashion Accessories, etc Pants, Shirts, Trousers, Shoes, Belts, Sunglasses, Bags, And Many More For Man, Women And Kids. Every Thing Fashion Related items for every one.
http://thebocaratonalist.com/

Reply
shahidsaleemali link
4/25/2014 12:03:22 am

very Hopeful and nice ideas for green Houses. And forming relative items and accessories.
http://sunwaterseed.com/

Reply
shahidsaleemali link
4/25/2014 12:03:58 am

Many ideas and tips for earn money in home. How to earn Online money on internet.
http://specialriskonline.com/

Reply
karwanpak
4/25/2014 01:02:47 am

Its really bad to know that your lawyer gave you bad advice.


EASYCLICKADS.COM
TRAVELCOSTHELPER.COM
TORONTONIAGARAFALLSBUS.COM

Reply
shahidsaleemali link
4/26/2014 12:08:16 am

Information for Study Visa, Business Trip, Holiday Trip And Other Visa Information. And Know Prefect Hotel And Places.
http://www.northcyprustrip.com/

Reply
shahidsaleemali link
4/26/2014 12:09:16 am

Most Wanted Recipes For Anytime And Every One. Baby Food, Chicken Recipes, Pasta Recipes, Healthy Food, Ice Cream And Others. Know For Kitchen Tools And Cooking Techniques.
http://www.mostwantedrecipes.com/

Reply
muslimlove
6/2/2014 08:42:19 pm

Your teacher is just grading all outputs of the essay writing tasks that he or she assigns to you. So do not blame him or her if your recently-submitted essay didn't pass his or her standards.

Best Regards
sleepy-hollow-design.com
clayton-usedcars.com

Reply
muslimlove
6/6/2014 10:50:51 pm

Its really bad to know that your lawyer gave you bad advice. It is always advisable to concern with more then one lawyer before taking the action.

Best Regards
fullservice-bigsavings.com
aquasoleilspa.com
hotel-austral.com

Reply
jhonhappy
6/9/2014 08:12:11 pm

very Hopeful and nice ideas for green Houses. And forming relative items and accessories.

Best Regards
fullservice-bigsavings.com
aquasoleilspa.com
hotel-austral.com

Reply
jhonhappy
6/10/2014 07:19:07 pm

Its really bad to know that your lawyer gave you bad advice. It is always advisable to concern with more then one lawyer before taking the action.


Reply

Your comment will be posted after it is approved.


Leave a Reply.

    DISCLAIMER: If a blog post you read here contains case results, be advised that case results depend upon a variety of factors unique to each case. Case results do not guarantee or predict a similar result in any future case.

    Authors

    Sharifa Abbasi, Esq.
    Hassan M. Ahmad, Esq.
    Humza Kazmi, Esq.
    Faisal Khan
    ​Valeria Prudencio
    Carly Stadum-Liang, Esq.

    Archives

    September 2020
    August 2020
    July 2018
    June 2018
    April 2018
    March 2018
    February 2018
    January 2018
    December 2017
    November 2017
    October 2017
    September 2017
    July 2017
    June 2017
    May 2017
    April 2017
    March 2017
    February 2017
    January 2017
    December 2016
    November 2016
    October 2016
    September 2016
    August 2016
    July 2016
    June 2016
    May 2016
    March 2016
    February 2016
    January 2016
    December 2015
    November 2015
    August 2015
    June 2015
    May 2015
    April 2015
    March 2015
    February 2015
    January 2015
    May 2014
    April 2014
    January 2014
    December 2013
    November 2013
    October 2013
    September 2013
    August 2013
    July 2013
    June 2013
    May 2013
    April 2013
    March 2013
    February 2013
    January 2013
    December 2012
    October 2012
    September 2012
    August 2012
    July 2012
    June 2012
    April 2012
    January 2012
    December 2011
    August 2011
    March 2011
    February 2011
    July 2010
    April 2010
    March 2010
    February 2010

    Categories

    All
    Appellate
    Asylum
    CBP
    Citizenship
    Constitutional Rights
    Criminal
    DACA
    Deportation
    Family
    Framing
    General
    H 1B
    H-1B
    Hma Law Firm
    Immigration
    Immigration Policy
    Immigration Reform
    International
    Interns
    Muslim Ban
    National Security
    Politics
    Removal
    Syria
    Tanton FOIA Lawsuit
    Trump
    Waivers

    RSS Feed

Quick Links

  • Our Team
  • Practice Areas
  • Executive Action
  • Consult

Contact Info

8133 Leesburg Pike, Ste 801
Vienna VA 22182

Tel:  703.964.0245

Fax: 703.997.8556
Email: info@hmalegal.com

Subscribe to the HMA LawFeed

Picture

​Pay Fees Here

Book you consult online by clicking on this link now!

©2009 - 2021 by Hassan M. Ahmad. All rights reserved. No portion of this website may be copied or reproduced for any purpose without express written permission.

Photos used under Creative Commons from Beshroffline, Thorne Enterprises, alex-s, swanksalot, 401(K) 2012, hyku, Gage Skidmore, Gage Skidmore, michaeln3, Antony J Shepherd, Korean Resource Center 민족학교, Don Fulano, lewebafricain, Images_of_Money, Lord Jim, Kevinth Nunez, Joe Crimmings Photography, Cohen.Canada, Thane Eichenauer, Gage Skidmore, CGP Grey, digitalshay, anokarina, Debbie Ramone, slightly everything, loop_oh, aaron_anderer, U.S. Marshals Service, tsuacctnt, Andrew Feinberg, Official U.S. Navy Imagery, Soggydan, Keith Bacongco, photosteve101, Emery Co Photo, futureatlas.com, david_terrar, weiss_paarz_photos, juanktru, Anh Le Tran's Photogphy, Amanda M Hatfield, IcronticPrime, Fibonacci Blue, blvesboy, Carl Montgomery, zappowbang, khawkins04, kennethkonica, opensourceway, Supernico26, mynameisharsha, JBrazito, Glyn Lowe Photoworks, Justin A. Wilcox, Wesley Fryer, MAClarke21, khalid Albaih, Chairman of the Joint Chiefs of Staff